As noted earlier, the U.S. Supreme Court today turned down Kelli Ward’s request they keep T-Mobile from turning over her cellphone call records to Congress’ January 6 Select Committee. So, what will happen next?
The AZGOP Chair has been fighting this subpoena since February. District Court Judge Diane Humetewa dismissed the case in September. Since then, each court – Humetewa, the 9th Circuit and now the Supreme Court – has refused to stop T-Mobile from complying while an appeal of the dismissal is proceeding.
Before now turning over the records, T-Mobile will now ask the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals to allow Judge Humetewa to CLARIFY her October 7 ruling. In that decision, there seemed to be some confusion about whether the Jan. 6th Committee had agreed to narrow its subpoena to (somehow) exclude the phone numbers of possible patients of Dr. Ward (and her physician husband, Michael).
After Committee attorneys had noted that they were not interested in the possible patients’ info, the Court had encouraged the parties to try to narrow the subpoena to restrict them.
Ward’s attorneys argued that there should be a protective order preventing patients’ identities (e.g. phone numbers that would be investigated) from being turned over. “(T)he Select Committee should not be permitted to play fast and loose with its intentions when arguing hotly contested motions relating to unprecedented matters of such importance that they are now being scrutinized by the Supreme Court.”
However, on November 4, Judge Humetewa said that, when asked by the 9th Circuit for a clarification, she would tell them that the subpoena is not narrowed. “Nevertheless, it remains implausible for T-Mobile to parse out those patient phone numbers and, despite this Court’s encouragement, the parties apparently have not discussed a process by which to do so.”
It will probably now take several days or a few weeks for the Ninth Circuit and Judge Humetewa to go through the process. With the uncertainty still existing about which political party will be in control of the House of Representatives – and, the Committee – in January, those days or weeks may be critical to when and whether Ward’s phone records are turned over and subsequently investigated.
This article was reported by AZ Law founder Paul Weich. Paul was running for a seat in Arizona’s House of Representatives.
“AZ Law” includes articles, commentaries and updates about opinions from the Arizona Supreme Court, U.S. Supreme Court, as well as trial and appellate courts, etc. AZ Law is founded by Phoenix attorney Paul Weich, and joins Arizona’s Politics on the internet.